I have not had any problems with rattling. The thing that really eritates me is that the are wobbaly when 3/4 of the way up until closed. It doesn't make any noise though. If they are half way down, it is fine. I didn't notice any difference in the wind noise from the stock windows. My old windows rattled a lot, but I think it was because of my window regulator. I replace it with a power regulator, and have not had any more rattles or squeks out of my doors since. I am glad about that. They are not good if you want to leave your window cracked.
------------------
http://www.geocities.com/a68rod