View Single Post
Old 05-07-2010, 01:35 PM   #10
Critter
Future TOTM Winner
 
Critter's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Bulverde, TX
Posts: 2,692
Re: Need help finding band saw

Quote:
Originally Posted by LONGHAIR View Post
Finding one that will run both is a compromise at best. You really can't run both at the proper speed for either. Metal cutting saws run much slower than wood cutters. You can "in theory" run a wood blade on a metal saw, but it will not cut as is should. Sure, it's moving, so it will cut, but it will wander in straight cuts and tend to burn during curves. It may sound crazy the "slow" would burn, but it does happen with wood when you don't "clear" the chips out quickly enough.

...and if you run a metal cutting blade at the speed of a wood cutting saw, it burns the teeth right off of it. I have seen articles written about sawing like this though. Essentially you burn the teeth down to nubs and "burn" your way through the cut by friction. This is a fire hazard though if the saw has ever cut wood, of ever will again.

As a machinist turned cabinet maker, I can tell you that wood and metal are very different to cut...and very few tools cut both. Heck wood is so picky that it matters what direction you are cutting.
All good points. While I started this thread because I was curious about NEW metal saws, alot have said to convert wood to metal. I am considering this as well. Your post above says your can't run metal blades at wood speeds and visa-versa. I agree, but what I have seen others do and would consider myself is buy a cheap wood version at a garage sale or pawn shop or something and "re-pully" it so that the speeds are slowed down for a metal blade. I have personally seen two craftsman models converted in this way and they work fine for the home shop. I wouldn't be using this on a commercial scale so I could probably get by with it.

None the less, I would still like to find a decent vertical metal saw at a reasonable price, but maybe they just don't exist.

There is always something like this but I don't have much faith in Northern/Harbor when it comes to tools like this. I think they can be fitted with a horizontal bench.
__________________
72 Chevy CST K5 HIGHLANDER BLAZER Getting a 6.0,NV4500,NP205,14BFF (Currently laying all over the place in little pieces)
72 Chevy swb step-side "LS" 6.0 Here's a build thread of sorts
2002 HD2500 Crew Cab, 8.1L Allison 4x4 Daily Driver

Check it out www.lsdyno.com

Last edited by Critter; 05-07-2010 at 01:36 PM.
Critter is offline   Reply With Quote