[tubbedII]

I haven't personally purchased either, but read a lot of threads on them. From what I've read, there's really not a big difference and more of a personal preference. I'd base my decision on 2 things: 1. Which block off plate you like better on the firewall (If you're smoothing the firewall yourself then this doesn't matter) and 2. Which inside control you like better.

Vintage Air is probably more expensive due to their advertising.