contact this ebay seller -
http://myworld.ebay.com/csm1986&ssPa...84.m1543.l2533
or give Jonathan (VA72C10) a holler - he may be able to help. He helped me find a full set (incl glovebox and alum insert).
Having said that - I kind of agree with the comments above, if only 60K (and if that is YOUR truck in the first post), I think it looks great and I wouldn't touch it. Or see if you can somehow get the original replated without destroying the woodgrain. I do agree, vinyl woodgrain stickers are hard to apply properly and they seldom match an existing glovebox woodgrain (or at least not a factory one).
The price of fame aint cheap though... I paid a pretty penny for my dash and glovebox parts - bought them together to ensure a match.