Well, last night I went with
AMD Tailgate - Plain Part# 925-4067-1. Came out ~6 dollars more than the from GMCPauls. Which Paul Jr. sent back my $$$ this morning before I even woke up. That was very quick, seeing that I requested my refund WAY after COB for them (and going into a weekend).
Stats of Tailgate:
TriPlus Automotive
Weight: 60.00 lbs
Gauge of Metal: 18 ga.
Reproduciton tailgate for the 67-72 Chevrolet / GMC C/K Fleetside Pickup, 1969-1972 Chevrolet Blazer & 70-72 GMC Jimmy
Stamped from 18 gauge, OE quality steel on new tools. Each premium tailgate features the correct shape, size, bends and holes, like original. EDP coated to help protect against rust and corrosion.
Here on the forms I read a few very old postings and they were not very positive on TriState. Though I read a number of positive reviews on these tailgates (Stepside, Chevy/GMC stamped, and Blanks) were the TriState part# matched at various resellers. I also called up AMD and they do not have a pattern of returns, other than ones that arrive damaged.
It is interesting that the one from GMCPauls is listed as 19 gauge and this one is 18 gauge. Anyways, so long as this one is exceeds the quality and strength of the one I am replacing, I'll be happy.