Floor Mat options?

[Toro]

I've searched here, and I keep coming across two options for front floor coverings. One is a full vinyl front mat from Stock Interiors, and the other is the OE style rubber floor mat that's sold at few places (Classic Parts, LMC, others). The OE style looks correct, and has the strips going back along the sill plate to rear edge, but it does not have full coverage under the seats. The vinyl mat has full coverage, but doesn't have the OE "look" or texture. If anyone has installed either of these, what are your thoughts?

Anyone have any other suggestions as far as mats go? I'm not really wanting to go with carpet.