Shifter and gear indicator questions

[Chevysdominate]

I have what I think is a 1972 column in my truck. I recently put the shifter arm and gear indicator back onto the column. The truck was a floor shift for a while and the shifter and indicator are not the original ones from this column, but they seem to fit just fine. Now when the shifter is in park the indicator doesn't line up. When the shifter is all the way down the indicator is way past the first gear indicator. This is all without linkage going to the transmission.

Do I have the right shift indicator?

The first pic is the shifter arm in the park detente position.