Glove Box Door Button Problems

[Mayo]

My old button was having problems, it would kind of freeze up and you'd have to smack it a few times to get it open, so I replaced it with a new one from LMC back in December or January. That lasted about two months before it completely fell apart, so I put my old one back in. I found out the new one was under warranty, so LMC replaced it for me and that one just did the same exact thing today. I went to put my old one back in, and as soon as I got it in it fell apart too. Am I just on a string of bad luck or are the new ones no good? The inside of my box has gotten leaks in it before so its a little deformed. It rubs on the arm on the right side causing the door to not pop open as soon as you hit the button. Coulds that play a part in my buttons breaking, or do you think my latch might be messed up? Thanks.