New Shift Lever Won't Fit

[ajgriffin]

So my truck has has a B&M floor shifter in it since I've owned it and I decided I want to switch back to the column shifter. The column is a standard, non-tilt column.

I picked up a new lever from Classic Industries for a 69 and....it doesn't fit. Checked the levers for a 67-68 and a 71-72 while I was at Classic and those didn't fit either. I got the truck from my Dad who's with the Lord now so I can't ask him, asked the previous owner if they changed the column and they didn't remember swapping it out so I don't know what else to do.

I snapped some photos of it so you can see what I'm talking about. Any ideas what I should try next?