Would YOU do it?

[72chevyk10]

to be honest id rather have the dodge. never had a problem with one. my chevy is CONSTANT problems

[sjarrett71]

Ok, I'm at work this morning so let's see if I can post pics from here. Here are the two trucks for comparison:

Ok, so I can't post pics. Here are the two Craigslist ads:

MINE:

http://stlouis.craigslist.org/cto/1532551042.html

HIS:

http://columbiamo.craigslist.org/cto/1532657726.html

[jamesi20]

" i have lost interest in it "translates...I'm tired of working on it...keep the Dodge and save your money for a classic later.

[big_al_71]

Originally Posted by mikey531

You are forgetting one very important item... What does your Father-In-Law say about it ?

that is the first thought that came to my mind!!!!





In a chevy forum what do you think the majority is going to say?



So, did you trade for it yet?

[Sammy]

I previously had seen the Dodge CL posting. I try to stay aware of possible deals. I agree with most of the replys so far. Maybe you can delay the trade for a few weeks warmer weather has to arrive soon or work something out with Nate to use his garage for a Saturday afternoon. With his help it might speed up the process and keep you from getting frost bit too. Plus it may give you time to see how it floats over with the inlaws. And if the truck isn't in Rolla and closer to me, I have a sheltered heat here too. Of course don't let me talk you into something that is going to cause a rift on the home front. Idea of doing a conversion in -5 wind chill isn't in the best interest of ones health.

[sjarrett71]

Exactly Sammy, too cold to work on the truck outside. I thought about asking the guy to commit to the trade but hold off for warmer weather. We went to school together growing up so he should be cool with it, he said he's in no hurry but first come first served. My father in law would be cool with me trading, to him it's just an old truck that he used for transportation. He's not really into vehicles too much, especially older ones. The only one he misses is a 73 vette he used to own YEARS ago. He even mentioned that I could trade it off now that the 2nd car got sold.

[bobbo]

That is a very good looking chevy. As far as the trade, definitely consider the fuel mileage (or lack of). Big blocks can be expensive, but I understand if you don't drive it often. Very difficult decision. If it were me, I would do the trade, but wait until the weather clears up some. That way you have a four wheel drive while we still have snow...like today where 6-8 inches is forecast, at least down this way...My truck doesn't do very good in this crud, even with 4-60lb sand bags in it. But, as already said, do what makes you happy! I don't think it would be a bad deal, but consider reliability and cost. JUST FIX WHAT YOU HAVE ALREADY AND QUIT TRADING THEM BEFORE YOU DO ANYTHING!

[71meangreenc10]

Dodge looks pretty good to me......

Smitty

[3Speed68]

I have 2 trucks. One is a Dodge and one is a Chevy.



Advantages= 4x4, cruise control, its comfortable, automatic trans and it has a 360 engine, so mileage aint great, but hey I dont use it that much. It is a very comfortable truck with good pulling power and it is fantastic for hunting. I have never gotten stuck with it. Bought it new, had it since then and its an 01. No trans problems. So that being said, I like my Dodge.

Now my second vehicle is my Chevy.



Great truck- gets about 18-20 miles per gallon with the inline 6 and 3 speed trans. Advantages= its a good running truck with good looks. It is original, but not real comfortable and unless you want/can travel cross country without cruise control and the other luxuries, its really just for close travel. Besides it only goes 45mph max.


My advice- keep the Dodge and purchase a Chevy or the Chevy if you want it. A 454 is a gas hog, and that truck will require much work. I agree that the Chevy is not worth 3500 dollars. Its a 1000-1200 dollar truck to me. It will not be cheap to fix.

If the Dodge is running and paid for it is already saving you some money.

[mcbassin]

Originally Posted by 3Speed68

I have 2 trucks. One is a Dodge and one is a Chevy.
I agree that the Chevy is not worth 3500 dollars. Its a 1000-1200 dollar truck to me. It will not be cheap to fix.

If the Dodge is running and paid for it is already saving you some money.

Where can I find a truck like this for $1000-1200? I would probably buy it today!

[CG]

Im in the camp that thinks about the FIL. Id run it by him first. When I was younger I was given a decent 54 Chev truck by my then BIL. It wasnt running and I put a newer six in it, got tired of it and sold the truck. He was an unhappy camper.

Ever since then when Ive been GIVEN anything and its time to let it go, I ask the previous owner if its cool. Never been a problem. Could be the BIL was just a chump, I do think though it made me a better person to consider the gifters thoughts first.

[3Speed68]

Originally Posted by mcbassin

Where can I find a truck like this for $1000-1200? I would probably buy it today!

Having been stationed in Missouri- which is where that truck is, you can finde them cheap there. For some reason Misouri has very many old cars/trucks around for the collector. That one is in Crocker- close to St Robert. Its all country out there, plenty of trucks.

I'm cheap brother... 1200 max from me. he may get more from somewhere else, but really- thats just a 2wd half ton, nothin special, and it needs work. To me, not so great.

[COACHMEASON]

Never know...That Dodge might be worth something one day...That was the body style that turned it around for Dodge...

[sjarrett71]

My Dodge is not a 4x4, only a 2wd. I had a 95 Dodge 4x4 a few years ago and absolutely LOVED that truck! I got rid of it cause the trans was going out. I traded it for a 01 GMC and it was not like I was driving a truck anymore. Don't worry, before I trade I will talk to my father in law just to make sure.

[chevydog66]

WWTD What would Tiger do? Just do it!!

[sjarrett71]

OK-I've got an update. I am going this afternoon to look at this truck...I think I might like it better than the 70....

[mcbassin]

That is a nice looking truck! You know where to look for problems on these models as far as rust/rust repair? Good luck!

[LOW DOUGH]

TRADE it!

Oh, or get that one

[3Speed68]

That blue one rocks...that would be a good trade...IMO...

[big_al_71]

Originally Posted by sjarrett71

OK-I've got an update. I am going this afternoon to look at this truck...I think I might like it better than the 70....

I really like this blue one!!!

[Indyuke]

I'd agree on the blue one. Those models tend to be more comfortable than the 67-72 models, though the big tires are going to kill your fuel economy as well.

In looking at the pic of the grey 70, it looks like the heater isn't hooked up. That could be a bummer in cold weather.

[sjarrett71]

The guy that has the 70 said the heater was hooked up before he put in the big block and worked fine. His brother was also there and said he actually owned the truck before and also had the heater hooked up and it worked fine. The owner said he didn't hook it up because he wasn't planning on driving it in the winter. ???? is it's true or not.

[Rob H.]

As much as I like 67-72 Chevys, if I was gonna trade that blue 4x4 would win out over a 2wd anytime. I like the Dodges too, but only being a 2wd, I would trade it! If that blue one runs and is as solid as it looks, it'd be a very good trade! I never was too crazy about the square bodies, but have had alot of dealings with them and they're tough and fairly comfortable.

[ya it is a classic]

Originally Posted by Indyuke

I'd agree on the blue one. Those models tend to be more comfortable than the 67-72 models, though the big tires are going to kill your fuel economy as well.

In looking at the pic of the grey 70, it looks like the heater isn't hooked up. That could be a bummer in cold weather.

ya but i think the 454 would be worse. besides those tires are only like 33s? i would call him up today and go get it!!!!

[brad_man_72]

even people on a dodge website would tell you to trade for the chevy!
i guess after your last 67-72 chevy trade you know what to look out for.
good luck with whatever you decide. ive got some decent front sheetmetal for that 70 if you need it.