Vent weatherstrip comparison

[Skunksmash]

Originally Posted by INSIDIOUS '86

So will one seal better than the other?

Don't mean to sound too negative, but you'll be in for some hassle trying to get those things to fit. In my opinion they technically don't fit. It really sucks that whoever made them originally doesn't anymore. Not that I could find anyway. They'll go on there, and I'm sure they're very durable and will last 20 years just like the old ones. But that doesn't mean they fit well.

You'll have 1/8th inch gaps all over the place once you're finished, and the noise level is of course unacceptable. I ended up having to use that black RTV silicone pretty much everywhere, and I still have yet to iron out all the air noise and whistling. Not even the old cracked and half rotted originals made that much noise. And the new ones are a lot thicker. I'd say at least twice as thick, maybe more. That makes them even harder to work with.

I think Precision needs to go back to the drawing board, and try to make them more like GM did. They might be able to turn it around if they made a very detailed instruction manual that they included with all the seals, that no only addresses how to install them but how to make them seal up perfectly, addressing each and every point that air is going to leak in. But I think that would mean that you're just going to be siliconing them in, everywhere they are supposed to be up against the metal. Or maybe make some very detailed videos on installing both the 1 piece and the two piece designs, showing exactly how to get rid of ALL the gaps and all the air noise. Just thought I'd warn people what you're in for.